[HP4GU-FAQ] Re: Dilemna with My First FAQ (response and general comments)

[Neil Ward]

Penny wrote:

>I like the idea of posing questions that seem to be unanswered for
>further discussion points.  And I think you're right that this is
>especially true for the character FAQs.  By the by -- I did a brief
>character sketch of McGonagall on another listserve (hpanonymous) in
>response to someone's argument that JKR's female characters are weak.
>Should I forward my thoughts or save it to raise with the group later?

***

I posed the 'posing questions' idea and then went off it.  On second
thoughts, I suggest we cut our suit according to our cloth. If the
McGonagall piece looks thin (there's arguably enough material to make a pair
of socks for Dumbledore), it might encourage some new thoughts.  The same
goes for any other thin topic.  

Penny, I'd suggest keeping your MM piece up your sleeve for later, as it
might trigger some discussion. If I plonk it in the FAQ on its own now, it
could just sit there unnoticed.

Neil (who hasn't actually looked at the McGonagall messages yet and may be
surprised)  

            Flying-Ford-Anglia

 *****************************************

   "Then, dented, scratched and steaming, 
   the car rumbled off into the darkness, 
   its rear lights blazing angrily"

 [Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets]

 *****************************************