Is JKR off-topic?

[lucky_kari]

--- In HP4GU-FAQ at y..., "bluesqueak" <pipdowns at e...> wrote:
> I've reached the discussion of the unauthorised biography. Catalogue 
> it as JKR Biography, or just mark it OT?
> 
> Pip!Squeak
> 
> (Oh, and I've added 'Student Numbers'and 'Name [as in meaning of]to 
> the categories.

Didn't Cindy say we'd be using "Etymology" rather than "Name", when
categorizing name meanings? That's what I've been doing at least....

"Student Numbers" = Number of Students at Hogwarts, right? Adds that
to list.

JKR Biography would only be on topic, I would think, if it's connected
to canon. For example, if someone was discussing the unauthorized
biography and mentioned a parallel between Hermione and Rowling.
However.... we do have a JKR FAQ, don't we? So maybe it should be
marked as JKR Biography.

You're marking posts as OT btw? I'm just blacking them out.

Eileen