The Ickiest HP theory ever

[lucky_kari]

--- In HP4GU-FAQ at y..., Amy Z <lupinesque at y...> wrote:
> Thanks, and it's greatly tempting, because *I* haven't
> laughed as hard as I am right now over Pip and
> Elkins's manic responses (Prometheus--LOL!), but I
> will resist.  It's a bit mean to Finwitch, first off. 

Oh, I don't think anyone will connect it with the eyeball thing. 

> Then, too, I don't want to bear any of the
> responsibility for the list devolving into IHPTfBDGU
> (Insane HP Theories for Bipolar-Disordered Grownups). 
> I suspect it's too late already (Imperio'd Molly?),
> but why add to the problem?

How about posting it on the OT List, like Elkins did with her
E.L.G.I.N.M.A.R.B.L.E.S. post a long way back? ("Lily was Nice!") Then
we all chime in with our supporting canons. B/C it's entirely too
funny to keep to ourselves. 
 
> Amy
> who has a deliciously grim feeling that this thing is
> going to appear on the main list next week, grown to
> 48k and with footnotes and references to Lacan,
> courtesy of certain FAQers Who Must Not Be Named. 
> Marina, save me!

You want more canon, btw, for the liver thing?

It explains a question that has been plaguing Harry and us a while.

What did Snape do to gain Dumbledore's trust? Cindy suggested that
Snape had to sacrifice Rosier and the others, but the truth now is
apparent. 

Eileen