[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: Proposed changes to reject categories - pl. comment

Barry Arrowsmith arrowsmithbt at btconnect.com
Tue Jul 27 14:58:12 UTC 2004


Apart from my instinct telling me to agree with Anne re keeping Fan-Fic 
as a separate recognisable category, folding the reject categories 
together seems reasonable.

Does that mean we can invent some more? Like :
Boring
Whiner
Pompous prig
Self congratulatory

More seriously, we have categories for DD's agenda, Voldy's agenda; 
would it be useful  to have a category for Motivation/Suggested 
Motivations for use with all the other characters?

OK - Fantastic Posts again. A possible contender - 6942.
May be contentious for some - it's a FILK. (Never thought I'd consider 
one of those.) Nice and witty with a marked Tom Lehrer influence, IMO. 
(It gives a precis of the running plot in all four books to date.) Do 
we want to try and get FP examples from most/all categories of post? So 
we end up with the best FILKs, best TBAYs, best commentary, best 
analysis, best theorising - or do we pit each against the others by 
measuring against some objective standard?

Also - I've now finished my current allocation.

Barry





More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive