BTW

[a_reader2003]

--- In HPFGU-Catalogue at yahoogroups.com, Barry Arrowsmith 
<arrowsmithbt at b...> wrote:
> > Well, there's a thread of predictions based on a rumour (yes, I 
know it should be rejected) starting  at 2903. It seems a shame to 
throw it in the bin - the predictions are entertaining but based on a 
falsehood. Do these get counted as valid predictions (remembering 
that at the time no-one had a clue what was coming) or are they 
apocrypha, to be cast into the outer darkness?
> 

Carolyn:
I'd put it in non-canon predictions..why not, its quite fun, and in a 
way, not totally wrong as he nearly did get expelled in OOP. Maybe at 
the time this rumour happened that plotline was still in GOF.