Sirius & Harry posts

[snow15145]

Carolyn:

Kathy, I'd completely forgotten you'd stepped forward to do this one,
sorry! I thought it was still unallocated, should have checked.

Snow:

No problem, I wouldn't want your headache
oops I mean job :-)

Carolyn:

On a Marauders' code -

A) If the post is about parallels between them and the kids (or
anyone), I think the existing 1.2.10.5 Generational parallels between
characters is the right category to use.

Snow:
Do you mean to code these posts only to parallels and not to cross 
code to the individuals as well? These posts have 1.2.10.5 ticked as 
well as trio dynamics and each of the marauders by name so I thought 
it would be easiest to follow suit and tick a marauder code rather 
than the three or four individuals that have also been ticked. 

Carolyn:

B) If we have a Marauders' Dynamics code, then it should purely be
about the relationships between MWPP, but it probably should not
include the Shrieking Shack/Prank incidents. Is this too
complicated/too fine a distinction for people to remember?

Snow:

I suppose I viewed this code, the marauders, more from a collectively 
speaking aspect than a dynamics of the marauders viewpoint. I feel 
that when I am reading the category heading about Sirius that I would 
expect to find topics that basically discuss him, `Dead Sexy Sirius' 
and the like. If the post is about at least three of the four 
marauders and goes into what part each played in the prank for 
instance, I would like them to be under a specific area heading and 
not under the main subject heading of Sirius, Lupin, Pettigrew and 
James. When and if the thread veers off to only speaking of one or 
two of the marauders, I would then tick it off to the individual. 
There are also posts on what animagus each become that involve the 
group collectively, which would be better addressed under a group 
heading of the marauders, again if we are cross coding to the 
individuals involved as well as the subject matter of animagus. 

I hope I've explained my viewpoint better this time around. 


Snow