Graveyard scene/Blondes/Character's ages& codes/Dormice

carolynwhite2 carolynwhite2 at aol.com
Wed Apr 13 19:06:03 UTC 2005


Kelly:
Does the new 1.2.8.9 Graveyard re-birth (GoF) category include
discussion about what Voldemort's plan was if the kill-Harry part 
went as planned? 

I'm strongly leaning towards using 1.2.8.9, since the post really is 
discussing Voldy's hypothetical agenda during that scene, unless
there are any objections.

Carolyn:
I'm ok with coding it to Voldie's agenda and 1.2.8.9. Once I get to 
that post under the agenda heading, I'll have made a decision about 
whether to keep it on repetition or other grounds.

******************
KathyW:
I've come across discusions on physical descriptions and possible
meanings. For the time being I've put it under 3.4.3 Physical types
and metabolism but it sort of fits under 3.4.6 grooming. Only it 
isn't either. It's a case of how does beauty/ugly fit with magic or
expectations. Or "what do the different types of noses mean?" I'm
sure at some point there will be/was a discussion about hair
color/magic and height/magic.

Carolyn:
Is this the 'JKR doesn't like blondes' discussion that comes up from 
time to time?? Always thought it a bit odd, since she is blonde. I 
agree your choice of codes sounds alright, unless it gets into one of 
the moral arguments about appearances vs true character.

************
KathyW:
Carolyn, I'm going to do a batch of 100 codes then go review
characters' ages. Unless there is a different heading you'd rather I 
do.

C- no, I thought you were doing that section anyway. Could you double 
check that you are listed as such in both review DB??

*******************
Kelly:
To those of you reviewing the huge character codes (i.e. Harry, 
Snape, etc.), should I use a character code when a specific event 
involving that character is being discussed? For example, a thread 
discussing Snape's reaction to Sirius' appearance in GOF The Parting 
of Ways. Just code to the chapter, or add Snape and Sirius codes as 
well?

Carolyn:
I would add the character code, and leave it the brave reviewer to 
sort out. Only way forward, alas.

**********

Pip
::sliding gently back into the bottom of the teacup for another
snooze::

C- Now where is Dot, our resident ecologist? She'd know all about the 
hibernation habits of dormice.







More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive