[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: another moment of confusion

[ewe2]

On 4/16/05, corinthum <kakearney at comcast.net> wrote:
> Now me:
> 
> I'll echo the confusion on this one.  I use it only for posting
> mistakes, i.e. the poster should have known the detail at the time he
> or she posted.  I've mentioned before that I don't think we should
> toss well-developed theories (or even not-perfectly-developed)
> theories based on the fact that subsequent books proved them wrong,
> because these theories are part of the history of this list.  Someone
> may want to look up Fourth Man even knowing it was wrong.
> 
> -Kelly

If it's in the VFAQ, or JKR has ruled it out, I think it's fair to
reject: Fourth Man is quite valid to keep around, but insisting that
Sirius is in Slytherin is not.

-- 
Emacs is an alright OS, but it lacks a decent editor.