[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: another moment of confusion

[Ginger]

ewe2 <ewetoo at gmail.com> wrote:

If it's in the VFAQ, or JKR has ruled it out, I think it's fair to
reject: Fourth Man is quite valid to keep around, but insisting that
Sirius is in Slytherin is not.


Ginger:  Thank you (and Deb, Kelly and Jen too!)

This makes sense now.  Basicly, if someone says "I think this will happen."  Or "According to my theory, this would be so." then we keep it (assuming it holds to standards).  But if they say "I think Remus' middle name was Harry." then we kick it out as JKR has stated it was John.  

So, in other words, if it is part of list history, we keep it, if it is something that came as a result of poor reading or mind altering substances, it goes out.  Not that some good theories may not have had mind altering substances involved.

Any more thoughts?

Ginger, who thinks she may as well keep The Eternally Confused as a moniker.


		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
 Plan great trips with Yahoo! Travel: Now over 17,000 guides!
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://archive.hpfgu.org/pipermail/hpfgu-catalogue/attachments/20050416/d972f82a/attachment.html>