[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: Seventh Son stuff

[Ginger]

Sean wrote:
> In my last batch SST (Seventh Son Theory) and SDT (Second Daughter 
Theory)
> made up at least a quarter of the posts, and they were all 
standalone. This
> isn't counting the TBAY theories on top of that. The Missing 
Weasley Child has
> been around for ages, and would count under the same category too. 
And since
> we're able to talk about SST in such a way, should it not be a 
category then?

Potioncat: Just a reminder, don't code it to Weasley Age Gap. There 
was a lot of 7th son there. 


Ginger:  Sean, I am pretty sure we are coding consecutive numbered sections.  The one I did had a ton of 7th Son stuff, but it was tied to I/Arthur or the like.  Perhaps it did stand on its own later.  When I left off, people were arguing if I/Arthur would work without 7th Son and vice versa (or something like that).

Maybe if it has branched out we should give it its own.  Does it still tie in to Seer!Ron?  


On another topic:
>Sean: And what happened to TBAY? Was Hurricane Jo so destructive 
that it was
> simply given up? Or were the major players bored with it? 

Potioncat:
What does happen to the better posters? Very few hang around. I know, 
at some point it's all been said too many times. But does anyone 
think some of these authors will re-appear after HBP? 

Ginger:  I'd give my eye teeth (which are actually still intact!) to have Captain Cindy, The Elkins, Eileen, the MDDT, and others like that back.  Pippin is still among us, but I haven't seen her at the George drinking her odd red-coloured liquid in a coon's age.

To be honest, I expected TBAY to pick up after the debris was hauled away.  After OoP came out, there were a few forays into the arena, but many just didn't get it.  Plus, after 4 books, the world was wide open.  Now it has been narrowed down.  

Once upon a time, I said offlist (was it to Potioncat?  It was someone who joined up at the time of OoP) that TBAY would come alive again, and we'd have ringside seats.  I also stated once upon a time that there was no way on God's Green Earth that Darth Vader was Luke's father.

The list has changed since then.  We've doubled, and, as with all things which are a sum of their parts, we've evolved.  Unfortunately, we seem to have lost our BAY.

Ginger, thanking Kelly (?) (bad memory, like a steel seive) for the advise on the quill.


		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
 Yahoo! Small Business - Try our new resources site! 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://archive.hpfgu.org/pipermail/hpfgu-catalogue/attachments/20050428/8a21a5d0/attachment.html>