New & horrid task - our first review

severelysigune severelysigune at yahoo.co.uk
Sun Feb 13 22:42:06 UTC 2005


> 1.1.4 Equality & fairness - Eva

This category comprised 104 posts when I looked it through. The great 
majority of those deal with the House Elf Question. Then there are 
also smaller numbers dealing with:
- racism (race; blood; werewolves)
- class
- male/female
- stereotyping
- favouritism (Snape; Dumbledore)
- House rivalry
- treatment of Squibs
- wizard/Muggle relations, interaction, disdain
- power abuse (Snape; Moody; the Dursleys)
- rule breaking 

Only one post didn't seem to belong in the category at all (but I may 
just have missed the whole point of it, of course :-).

Most of the posts in 1.1.4 have also been coded under more specific 
labels, such as

1.1.1.5.1 (rule breaking);
1.1.1.5.3 (respect for authority);
1.1.6.1 (Child abuse & mistreatment);
1.4.0 (originality & use of stereotypes);
1.4.3 (Portrayals of males/females/gays);
3.2.2 (relationship with Muggle world);
and
3.2.6 (Class system, racism & bigotry).

Does the more specific category make their coding under 1.1.4 
redundant, or do we want to adopt the system 'general'+'specific'?


BTW, Carolyn: I have finished my batch and have, I think, picked up 
all the posts that were still 'open'; I patiently await my next 
ration :-).

Eva







More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive