Report on Fudge

carolynwhite2 carolynwhite2 at aol.com
Mon Feb 21 23:53:57 UTC 2005


As a diversion from trying to sort out the Spying section, I have 
reviewed the Fudge category (294 posts).

On the whole, it was an easy section to do. Fudge doesn't get a lot 
of page time, so the analyses tend to focus on the hospital scene at 
the end of POA, and the Dementor incident in GOF, plus sundry 
character sketches. There is really only one big Fudge theory, which 
is Eloise (& Dicentra's) ESE! allegations. These posts are caught 
under the various acronyms. So far, the posts mentioning the acronyms 
are very few in number (ones and twos), and could probably be easily 
collapsed together at some point, as they duplicate.

In all, I propose removing 122 references, reducing the current hits 
to 172.

The most problematic decisions to take were on the very big theories 
which got referenced in - the Avery Fourth Man (& numerous variants), 
chunks of the Memory Charmed Neville symposium papers, MAGIC 
DISHWASHER and so forth. On the whole, I suggest removing the actual 
massive posts themselves, but keeping some follow-up posts which 
conveniently dissect the Fudge element out of those theories.

Hope that's ok with everyone.

Carolyn







More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive