2.6.1-2.6.6 misc. girls review

Sean Dwyer ewe2 at aardvark.net.au
Wed Feb 23 04:55:14 UTC 2005


The Padma/Cho/Luna/Penelope/Fawcetts/Stebbins Review
====================================================

Initial posts: 146
Final posts:   134

Let's get the real nonentities out of the way first:

Luna:     0  posts not so surprising given the current level of cataloguing
Stebbins: 0  posts noone home
Fawcetts: 6  mostly along the lines of "who are they?" and mention in one incident
Padma:    11 and mostly in Parvarti's company, who gets more attention.
Penelope: 13 Percy-orientated except for #11101 and #35142. may as well not exist.

The only girl with any real showing is

Cho:     104

A disturbing thread starting with #20836 was rejected for OT racism (two
replies also culled), it was seen as such and I agree. One reply that had
other merit was retained.

I found the founding CINEMA post (#28588) but CONNIVING CHICKS REVENGE is still
missing.

An unrelated comment in a Cho-related multipost is probably my favourite funny
of the moment:

"My personal favourite theory is that Defeat The Dark Wizard Grindelwald is a
popular contest run annually by the Daily Prophet (who sponsor the Chocolate
Frog cards). Dumbledore won in 1945 and it has nothing more to do with
anything in the story." (dfrankis@ in #20908).

Otherwise the general Cho discussion was a war by Haters of Popular Pretties
vs. Defenders of Popular Pretties with a good smattering of She Done Cedric
Wrong (and won't we see a LOT more of that?!) and another Groupie Syndrome
member.

Sean


-- 
"You know your god is man-made when he hates all the same people you do."




More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive