From Kelly re spoilers and 3.16.5/3.16.5.1
carolynwhite2
carolynwhite2 at aol.com
Wed Jul 13 17:38:34 UTC 2005
Re spoilers on the list:
I would really appreciate it if spoilers are kept off the Catalogue
list,
since I'm reading the list via Daily Digest emails and therefore am
bound to
glimpse the spoilers even if spoiler space is provided.
Re my plans for HBP:
Both myself and one other Harry Potter fan on board are praying for a
weather divert so we can stop by a port early and get the book.
Barring
that, I'm hoping the Navy Exchange still has copies when I get into
port at
the end of the month. I plan to read it on the 13-hour plane ride
back
home, since I've given up trying to sleep on planes (took sleeping
pills on
the way out; didn't work).
And now some more reviews:
3.16.5 School discipline, general
---------------------------------
Originally: 75
Now: 26
For once, I didn't grow tired of a topic while reviewing; this
category
contained a little bit of everything. Most of which I threw out. :)
Because the title of this category is so vague and all-encompassing,
many
posts were placed here that fit much better in other categories:
teaching
methods, points sytem, prefects, following/breaking the rules, the
Prank,
etc. In all but four cases, they were already coded to said
appropriate
code in addition to 3.16.5.
I decided to reserve this category for posts that discuss Hogwarts
discipline systems and do not fit it any other categories. This
includes
predominately discussion of detention and expulsion.
3.16.5.1 Prefects & Head Boy/Girl
---------------------------------
Originally: 136
Now: 80
Discussion of prefect/head duties, how prefects/heads are chosen, and
future
prefect/head boy/head girl predictions (leading up to OoP). Most of
the
rejected posts were due to repetitious predictions for OoP prefects.
-Kelly
More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue
archive