Rock Solid Predictions/DD Question

annemehr annemehr at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 22 19:18:41 UTC 2005


Boyd: 
> > 
> > Now for Dumbledore:
> > 
> > I've managed a few hundred of these and have a question. Lots of 
> his posts
> > discuss why he wants socks, how old he is, and what his animagus is-
> -so is
> > cross-referencing the Mirror of Erised chapter, character ages and 
> animagi
> > sufficient, or shall we create a few new subcodes for him? I vote 
> the
> > former, assuming our search engine will be capable of looking for 
> posts that
> > belong to more than one category.
> 
> C - No, I would much rather you suggested a group of sub-codes as 
> Anne has done for Harry. If the post really belongs in one of the 
> other sections, then move it there, and un-code Dumbledore by all 
> means (and any other irrelevant codes, to save time). 
> 
> However, some useful sub-groups about DD would be really helpful.

Anne:
To elaborate a little on Carolyn's answer: to go the cross-referencing
route is to go into madness.  There are plenty of smaller categories
with posts that mention Dumbledore, or Snape, or Harry.  However, what
they have to say about those three (or LV; mustn't forget him) is more
than likely very much Adds Nothing New as far as the Big Four are
concerned.  Cross-coding to them is how the bloated categories got
that way in the first place.  It doesn't help keep any of the other
categories tidy, either.

~Anne,
brandishing machete and trying to look manacing







More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive