[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: cody stuffs/who does definitions?

[Sean Dwyer]

On Sat, Mar 19, 2005 at 09:42:48AM -0000, CarolynWhite2 wrote:

> Carolyn:
> The way I had envisaged this working was that the person who reviewed 
> the section should fix the definition, because they had just read all 
> the posts in it and had decided what to do with them. That's why I 
> put the reviewer's name on each one (I notice you changed Barry to 
> Sean on these ones that you changed).

> I dunno, but I am a bit concerned for someone else to come along and  
> change a definition subsequently on a section that they hadn't 
> reviewed. 
 
> As it happens, I don't think that Barry had looked at either of these 
> definitions yet, and it was still the old version sitting there, but 
> I have changed the reviewer name back to him on these two so we don't 
> lose track of who is supposed to be looking at what.

Fair enough. But one was incorrect and the other needed changing. I've no
problem if Barry disagrees with my definition, but what was there was pretty
useless. I changed the names so people knew who had edited those records,
there wasn't any other way of marking them besides mentioning it here. I know
I'm a naughty penguin, but that's penguins for you :)

> Carolyn:
> I just checked, and I wondered what you meant by 4 rejects, as you 
> seem to have kept the ones mentioned here (fortunately, as they are 
> on topic!). Perhaps you meant 4 rejects out of 100 posts? 

Yes, that is indeed what I meant, I was being most incomprehensibly
penguinistic, something to do with recent listening to Goon Shows, I suspect
:) And just to be OT but on the off-chance, does anyone have a recording of
the Last Goon Show Of All? I just got the DVD and it's cut for TV, missing out
some of the funny bits...

> The silver hand thing came up way back; I kept quite a lot in 
> Pettigrew, but the Lupin section hasn't yet been reviewed, or 
> werewolves, remedies for disposal of.

Yes, just a stray thought there, coding/reviewing really does set the old
HP4GU subconscious ticking...it really hadn't occurred to me until that post
came up.

> Sure thing: 43101-43200.

For whoever's doing 42900's, I have kept notes on the threads you will
encounter if you want the quick version :)

Round the back for the old brandy there...

-- 
When all you have are foxes, everything looks like a henhouse.