Room of Requirement predictions
corinthum
kakearney at comcast.net
Mon Mar 21 00:32:58 UTC 2005
Kelly:
> > Having just started the Bathrooms & loos subcategory, I've already
> > encountered quite a few posts suggesting that either the prefect's
> > bathroom or the chamber pot room might be the favorite room JKR
> > mentions in her interview. They're coded in all sorts of ways,
> > usually with some combination or permutation of 3.16.1.1 Bathrooms &
> > loos, 1.12.2.2 Predictions/no canon, and 3.16.1.2 Room of
> Requirement.
> > I assume I'll start finding these all over this category, so I
> > thought I should get some opinions on how to handle them.
> >
> <snip>
Carolyn:
> I'll leave Boyd to respond about the predictions aspect, but the
> original reason for this category is that there are lots of posts
> wondering about where the bathrooms and loos are, and whether the
> kids actually wash - outside the Room of Requirement speculation.
>
> It's hardly a gripping topic, but I suppose we need somewhere to put
> a selection of them.
Yes, I understand the purpose of the category (although I was thinking
of moving the "Do they bathe" posts to 3.4.6 Cosmetics % personal
grooming unless they specifically talk about existance of bathrooms at
Hogwarts).
I've decided that for now I'll move all these predictions to 3.16.1.2
Room of Requirement (if not already there) and 1.12.2.2 Predictions/no
canon (awaiting Boyd's input of the canon/no canon problem), and
remove individual location codes such as bathrooms & loos.
More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue
archive