Hello everyone/Filch

Jen Reese stevejjen at earthlink.net
Mon May 30 19:10:36 UTC 2005


Jen:
> In theory I agree completely with Carolyn, that in reviewing posts 
> we shouldn't presume to know more than another coder would know 
> about his/her section and make unilateral decisions. But in 
> principle ....

Responding to my own post. What I meant here was agreeing with 
Carolyn in theory but not in 'practice'. Just to reiterate, we don't 
know where some people are in their reveiws, and I *should* only 
review and un-code the category I'm in. But in reality it's 
difficult to leave a post a post alone when I know it may not be 
reviewed by launch time.  Esp. if it doesn't look coded correctly, 
is overcoded, or is in need of rejection. I'm placing my subjective 
view on the posts without looking at the category, true. The 
alternative seems to be letting the posts languish until they're 
reviewed. 

But others may not agree with this and if so, I'll stop un-coding 
anything but my own category when reviewing.

Jen, a bit grumpy during this GOF review. :(






More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive