[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: Relationship with Muggle world and Snape

[Ginger]

    Carolyn wrote:
  Ginger, multiple apologies for not having actioned this before. I 
will set up the categories straightaway. You want to have both 
History/Politics, and the sub-category 'Political Comparisons' ? Let 
me know if you want to adjust this.

  Ginger:
  No apologies needed.  You were sick and busy.
    Yes, I want both H/P and PC.  They are a bit similar, but there is enough difference and enough posts to merit both sections.  
   
  Basicly, H/P is about the relationship with the MW in the fictional setting, and PC is about how it compares to actual RL stuff.  
   
  H/P covers things like comparing the Apparation age to that of driving age, how a Wizard would go about getting a license to drive a Muggle car, the ethics of obliviation...things like that.
   
  The PC category is mostly comparisons of the WW situation to Hitler, Northern Ireland...things like that.
   
  Hope that makes that clear.  I'll do definitions if you feel they are needed.
   
  SNAPE:
  Are you sure we should have a category under Snape entitled "Who is Snape working for"?  Shouldn't it be "For whom is Snape working"?
   
  As to the other categories, your suggestions sound fine, but I'm not sure what other scenes we would have.  It seems there's a scene whenever we see Snape :)  Occlumency might come into play there when we do #5.  
   
  TBAY would sure save us a lot of acronym room.  Maybe as a temporary setting to be gone through later?  

Ginger, finishing Myrtle and Ghosts today, dementors tomorrow, and then will be done with Spirits.

		
---------------------------------
Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Make PC-to-Phone Calls to the US (and 30+ countries) for 2/min or less.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://archive.hpfgu.org/pipermail/hpfgu-catalogue/attachments/20060401/f97a73dc/attachment.html>