The Snape debate & dementors

Jen Reese stevejjen at earthlink.net
Wed Apr 5 03:15:49 UTC 2006


>   Ginger:
>   Yay!  Boyd's back! Now it's party time.  Rejoicing!  Gladness!  
Other good stuff!

Jen: He might be an imposter. There was no music, no dancing, no 
polyester.....Nah, hey Boyd! It's been too long, thanks for clearing 
up the DD question.



Ginger:
>   How the Kiss is administered would be under dementors, how the 
govt decided who should be Kissed would go under Azk/dementors, but 
discussions of what happens to the person who was Kissed really has 
more to do with the person and medical stuff than with the 
dementors, unless, of course, the post is discussing what happens to 
the soul of the person and the listee is wondering if that is how 
dementors breed or how often they have to eat or something like 
that, in which case it would remain under dementors.  Right?
>    
>   Let me know what you think.  I plan to rereview those 3 
categories and sort out the finer points this weekend.


Jen: I thought we didn't know for sure what happens to people who 
are kissed? I mean, whether they go to St. Mungos. What if there's 
nothing that can be done for them except, you know, to sort of 
exist. Course Barty Crouch Jr. didn't have a home to go back to so 
maybe he is in St. Mungos. (Do you ever have moments when the 
absurdity of what you're writing about hits you full on?<g>).  
Having not illuminated that issue at all, I'll go along with 
whatever you think is best. There.









More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive