Review of 3.8.4.1 Memory Charms
corinthum
kakearney at gmail.com
Sun Mar 26 18:03:01 UTC 2006
Question: When is 169 posts not 169 posts?
Answer: When half of them are written by Elkiins.
Sheesh, that woman can write.
Anyway, I finally finished reviewing 3.8.4.1 Memory Charms. I made
the decision, with the input of the group, that all the posts under
3.8.4 Spells, potions & incantations will be ones focusing on the
magical process itself, not the resulting characterizations and
plotlines associated with them. In this particular case, that means
that MemoryCharmed!Neville and all its variants shall remain under
Neville, Longbottom torture, a few dozen acronyms, and whatever other
character codes are deemed necessary, but for my purposes they went in
the trash.
Must admit, though, it was slightly traumatic for me to place the
Still Life with Memory Charm and Memory Charm Symposium posts in my
discard pile. :-) That conversation was one of the first ones I ever
read on this list (and one of the resons why it took me so long to
finish this review; it's so easy to be distracted by an Elkins thesis).
3.8.4.1 Memory Charms
---------------------
Originally: 169
Now: 38
Mechanism, process, regulations, morality, etc. of memory charms.
Only put character-specific posts (e.g. Neville, Harry, Bertha
Jorkins) here if the discussion is centering on the specific mechanism
of the memory charm. So, for example, a discussion of whether Neville
has been memory charmed (or any variant thereof) and why and by who
does not belong here, but a discussion of whether a memory charm could
produce the specific symptoms that Neville shows can stay.
-Kelly
More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue
archive