[HPFGU-Feedback] 5 Posts per day limit

[Jordan Abel]

> Shorty:
[regarding combined responses on multiple threads]
> FWIW, I don't think elves ever actually encourage *this* kind of combining
> of responses, Saitaina.  What is suggested is a combining of responses
> *within* a thread... and that is not a new suggestion.

Well, the problem as I see it is that it's never really made clear
what's encouraged, and even if it's not encouraged as such, in any
event the rule creates a dilemma between either doing that (which
breaks threading, is hard to read, hard to figure out, and generally
annoying) or limiting the number of threads one can participate in.

> Shorty:
> Shorty, avoiding some of the rationale discussion for now because she only
> ever seems to have about 5 mins. to devote to any one response!

I don't think the problem is the rationale - clearly there is a
problem that needs to be solved. I just think this may not be the best
way to do it.

Saitana:
> I always thought so long as the posts did something for the
> discusscion, were had substance and were far more then a one liner, that
> rule was ignored.

I think that even if this is not the case, it should be, and the rule
should be rewritten to reflect that.

--
Random832