[HPFGU-Feedback] Anger towards JKR (was Re: Great group / Quoted text)

[Schlobin1 at susanmcgee48176.yahoo.invalid]

In a message dated 10/21/2007 4:57:06 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time,  
va32h at ... writes:

Wow.  In your previous post you said the list was a little too mean
spirited for  your tastes and now you've just implied that people who
complain about DH  are out of touch with reality, emotionally
disturbed, mentally ill, and may  very well attack JKR!

Goodness gracious, if I were running the list I'd  have to plea for a
stop to this "JKR is an amazing woman and no one is  allowed to be
critical of her" notion.


Oh goodness no.....I'm not saying...please forgive me if I misspoke that no  
one should be allowed to criticize the work and the literature...I'd just like 
 there to be a little less personal attacks on the author's character and  
motives.....
 
And what I was saying, I'm sorry that I wasn't more clear, that when there  
is an atmosphere and permission for constant and out of touch with reality  
attacks on an author, that people who have mental health issues use that as  
fodder, and could become dangerous.
 
I am not suggesting that people who complain about DH are out of touch with  
reality! 
I have a whole list of complaints about DH. Complain away about DH!
 
I'm talking about people who impute the most horrible intent to JKR, who  
attack her personally.....who impute to her the most evil and machiavellian  
motives....
 
Susan



************************************** See what's new at http://www.aol.com


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]