Question about the meaning of the word "Immortal"

[ardhrianna at yahoo.com]

*SNIP*

> > (Moi:) So that makes me think that Nicholas will live
> > forever, with or without the Elixer from the
> > Philosopher/Sorceror's Stone.
> 
> (Monique:) Why do you assume with or without the Elixer? 
> 

I said "with or without the elixer" because he's already taken it 
once, so why should he have to take it again if he's Immortal and 
can't die?

O-kay.  FAR too much of Duncan and co.  :)  It's just bugging me.  
Thanks for replying!


C