[HPFGU-Movie] good luck bit...

[~Helen ~]

> 
>> Snape would 
>> never, ever under any circumstances, wish Harry Potter luck.  Would
>> anyone care to defend that scene?


Yes, I would. Actually, since it's been so long since I read #1, I
didn't know that this wasn't in the book. Anyway, it is incredibly
obvious (well, it was to me) that Snape was NOT particularly genuine
when he said good luck. As someone else said, he was trying to psyche
out Harry. I thought everyone else would have thought this too. I
mean, he's not exactly saying it in an incredibly friendly or
well-wishing way, is he?


On another note, I'm getting sick of reading newspaper and magazine
reviews that keep saying how much better Rupert and Emma were compared
to Dan. I mean, they were still very good, but I can't imagine either
of them inducing smiles and (almost) tears from me the way my little
man Dan did. He's a wonderful actor, and when I was reading GoF the
other day, I could really really "see and hear" him (well, a slightly
older version of him) as I read. I hope the movies end up going that
far, and that they can keep the same kids. 


Cheers,
Helen :o)


"She knows more about you than you do."
"Who doesn't?"
Ron and Harry, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone.

__________________________________________________________________
Get your free Australian email account at http://www.start.com.au