favorite lines (was [HPFGU-Movie] New poll for HPFGU-Movie)
Katze
jdumas at kingwoodcable.com
Tue Dec 18 04:54:10 UTC 2001
dominica wrote:
>
> I think the one where Ron asks Hermoine if she is a witch or not
> should have been included in the list..that's the one I wanted to
> pick...
>
I heard why that part of the movie was change. In the book, after the
chess game, Hermione and Harry leave Ron to go to he next puzzle. Ron
has just been hit upside the head, and Harry says, "He'll be fine", and
they move on. Columbus felt this was not so compassionate, and took that
scene out.
But that baffles me...because in the book Harry doesn't kill Quirrell,
where as in the movie he does. Granted Quirrell is bad, but Harry has
just killed someone! So...I guess it was a trade.
Anyway...that's what I heard.
I do love that part though...Are you a witch or not? Haha...her muggle
upbringing took over for a minute.
I also love the part where Harry realizes he has presents, and Ron says
something like, "What did you expect, turnips?"
I love Ron's character..he really brings a lot of light to the books.
-Katze
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive