Has Anyone Seen "Rings"? How Does It Compares to HP?

clio44a clio at unicum.de
Fri Dec 21 13:39:14 UTC 2001


I saw the LOTR movie in the opening night and I have to take back 
everything bad I sad about the HP movie (and I criticized a lot).
If compared directly I must say that I liked the HP movie better. But 
that might be just due to the general differences between the 
atmospheres of the books. HP is much more light-hearted and funny, 
LOTR is veeeery serious about heroship and such. You can't compare 
the 2 books or the movies for that matter. 
HP can be much better compared to The Hobbit instead of LOTR.

So liking LOTR is a matter of personal taste. It's like a Wagnerian 
opera, either you love bombastic music or not. I prefer HP over LOTR 
and Mozart over Wagner.
Nevermind, LOTR is a great movie. I just thought all the time: That's 
not Gandalf, that's Dumbledore. Switch the wizards, I`d say!

Clio,
who loves posts that don't really make sense






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive