[HPFGU-Movie] Re: HP vs LOTR

[Remy]

--- jazzyjedila at aol.com wrote:
> In a message dated 12/22/01 4:37:12 AM Central
> Standard Time, 
> HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com writes:
> 
> 
> > Which one would you recommend?
> > 
> > Now you will have to make a choice.  Harry Potter
> or the Lord of the 
> > Rings.  Only one movie.  That's all she will see. 
> Pick one.


LoTR DEFINITELY!!!!!!!
I would reccommend this movie to almost everyone
because it was STUNNING! 
Harry Potter left me feeling empty and angry because
it just wasn't as good as it could have been.

In the books, I'd choose Harry any day, I've never
read a book so many times and been so obsessed in my
life!

But in the movies, LoTR was unspeakably great. I read
the book last year and the movie really made the book
come to life.
It also made me mad, cause I wondered why couldn't
have Harry Potter been just as good. The obvious
reason is that they tried to do it in a year, but
still.

The actors were amazing, they REALLY fit their part;
the music fit in soooo well, it was perfect, it just
made evrything sooo much better; the whole story,
everything they kept for the movie, everything they
didn't. Just even little things to make it more
dramatic. 
And I had tears in my eyes for the whole last part of
the movie. It was simply and truly amazing and it will
be a classic.

I hate to admit this, but in my opinion(my opinion, to
make that clear), LoTR made Harry Potter look like
crap. 

And it does depend on the person, by the way. I know
they both have different stories, different everything
except for the fantasy aspect, but I'd still go and
see LoTR over HP anyday. I'm planning on seeing it
many, many more times. 






__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Send your FREE holiday greetings online!
http://greetings.yahoo.com