Shift in canon?

[Cindy C.]

Saitaina wrote:

Though I do like this better,
> James as Seeker makes more sense then James as Beater in terms of 
Harry'
> skill...

I agree, and I'll add that James as Seeker makes Snape's apparent 
jealousy more logical.  The Seeker is the star, so if James was 
strutting around with friends and admirers, he probably was a Seeker.

Cindy (wondering how Steve will handle this in the Lexicon)