[HPFGU-Movie] Movie Review (long, my apologies)

[Schlobin1 at aol.com]

In a message dated 11/17/2001 3:14:38 AM Eastern Standard Time, 
kris403 at yahoo.com writes:

<< .  Emma, I thought was adorable.  Yes, she could be annoying at 
 times, but remember, that is supposed to be her character.  I didn't 
 like her bathroom troll scene line though.  That one could have been 
 more believable.   >>

My response (after seeing the film for the second time) is that Emma in the 
scene where she is telling McGonagall the lie about the troll

is playing an extremely rigorous, bossy, pre teen who ALWAYS obeys the rules, 
never lies, and suddenly is LYING to a teacher --- her own head of house with 
Snape watching..so in a sense she's not SUPPOSED to be believable..