Harry...a murderer

[hertopos at hotmail.com]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "T" <supergirl1024 at y...> wrote:
> I was so upset when Harry killed Quirrel in the movie, rather than 
> having Dumbledore save him at the last minute, and Voldie leave 
> Quirrel to die.  It makes Harry an 11-yr. old murderer, and thats 
> just OOC..think Pettigrew.  So what does everyone else think?
> 
> T

I don't view the incident a murder. A human will not die like Quirrel 
did. The setting was necessary to make Voldermort's spirit appear.

I always think the ending of PS/SS the weakest of 4 books. I think 
the movie version improve it without losing the credibility.
Harry Potter is like a first level wizard.( Yes, I play D&D.) He 
cannot possibly fight against a full-grown wizard in a normal way.

Hertopos