Magic in the Movie

peacockharpy at yahoo.com peacockharpy at yahoo.com
Mon Nov 19 03:38:18 UTC 2001


--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "Barb" <blpurdom at y...> wrote:
> OTOH, why is it I remember hearing Dumbledore say in one 
> of the trailers that "no magics are to be done in the 
> corridors," but I don't recall him saying this in the 
> film either time I saw it...

All I remember him saying was no Dark Forest and no third floor
corridor, myself.  I'm seeing it again on Tuesday so I'll let you know.

> Also, much has often been made of Dumbledore performing wandless 
> magic (I love the way the banners change from Slytherin to 
> Gryffindor at the end of the film) but Quirrell and Snape also use 
> wandless magic during the Quidditch match; Quirrell to jinx Harry 
> and Snape to save him.  And when Quirrell flies at Harry near the 
> end, how is he doing it?  Is he able to do this because he's sharing 
> his body with Voldemort?  

Good point, Barb -- I don't think we're told much about wandless magic
by JKR, although it obviously exists (animagus changes, for example,
and Apparation).  Maybe it's more advanced and we'll learn more in a
later book?

I guess I would have liked to see more classroom work, or students
practicing charms in the background, or something.

- Darice





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive