Did anyone read my post?

[Cindy C.]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., hertopos at h... wrote:

> I am just wondering people here only read posts by the people they 
> know. I joined the group two days ago and I post a few. Some of 
them 
> was in a question form.
> 
> If I am not welcomed, maybe I should give up posting.
> 
> TWo questions I care are:
> 
> 1. Will this movie become a classic as Roger Ebert said?

I didn't think you'd like my answer, so I didn't respond at first.  
But if you really want to know:  

I don't think PS/SS will become a classic under my definition of a 
classic.  Classics include "The Wizard of OZ" and "Gone With The 
Wind" -- films that are very popular long after their original 
release, that pretty much everyone has seen, that make Big Stars of 
their stars, and that are brilliantly done in all respects.  Under 
that definition, I think PS/SS will just go down as being a good (and 
highly profitable) film.  See, you have to be careful what you ask 
for.  :-)

> 2. What do you think of possible 4 hour directors cut. There is an 
> online petition at www.petitiononline.com
> 


I don't have a DVD player.  That's why I didn't answer.  Nothing 
personal, you see.

Cindy