James & Lily in the Mirror of Erised

Tue Nov 20 00:24:34 UTC 2001

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., caliburncy at y... wrote:
> Sadly, for anyone that chooses to accept the movie as partial canon, 
> this fact puts some holes in the theory that several people have 
> espoused on the main list that Harry may see his family as he desires 
> them, not as they are.  

I guess I missed that discussion.  Doesn't the book provide sufficient info for 
that -- wouldn't Harry have noticed and commented, if the pictures  from 
Hagrid showed his parents looking different from the mirror?