Chamber Trailer Nitpicking

[millymarsh]

My thoughts on the following:

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "ickle_ronniekins" <ickle_ronniekins at y...>
wrote:
<<2. Why did the car have to be in front of the train? I like the
humor of the situation but aren't Harry and Ron supposed to be
keeping out 
of sight up above?>>

I think that it's just one of the sequences of the many that it takes
for the boys to get to Hogwarts. In the book they arrive at night I
believe or at
least around dusk.... so they may show a few more flying car scenes
in the 
movie.

<<3. I think there still won't be a Prof. Binns in this movie... it 
seems that McGonagall is doing the explaining of the Chamber legend 
to the students.>>

I agree about Prof. Binns. I don't think we'll get to "see" this
character:-(

Although, from a film making stand point, it makes sense to not have
to cast another teacher, the audience who is familiar with the movie
version
of the Harry Potter series, will be better able to identify
McGonagall as
she is familiar from the last film.
 
As for the rest of us, who have read the books, maybe they'll have
filmed something that got cut and include it in the DVD... um wait,
better
not go there, eh? (ducking tomatoes)

 
<< 4. Who's that lying petrified guy? Obviously not Nearly Headless
Nick -- too opaque. Not Colin -- black hair. Penelope and Hermione
are girls.
Justin is the only possibility left, but I think he's too big and
adult-looking for a
12-year old.>>

I don't think it's a petrified guy, I think it's either Crabe or
Goyle being dragged away into the closet for their clothes.

> 7. What spell did Draco do on Harry?

Not sure, but the choreography looks pretty fun so far!

Milly Marsh
Santa Monica, CA