All - Movie 'Mistakes' register

CB eleri at aracnet.com
Sat May 25 18:33:16 UTC 2002


At 11:48 PM 5/24/02 +0000, you wrote:
>Message: 5
>    Date: Fri, 24 May 2002 17:23:12 -0000
>    From: "feliciarickmann" <feliciarickmann at dsl.pipex.com>
>Subject: Re: All - Movie 'Mistakes' register
>
> > HP and the PS/SS is there with 50 recorded alleged errors. These
>are
> > Not book/film differences but things like Hagrid giving Harry the
> > photo album on the Station platform but when Harry gets onto the
> > train he isn't carrying a book.
> >
>
>Maybe someone can tell me WHY people go hunting for errors.
>
>This is not a criticism I would just like to know.  Once or twice I
>have found an odd thing but never to the extent of enumerating list
>of errors just for the * fun * of it? Is it a bit like train
>spotting??

I was reading through those the other day, for several movies, and there 
are some 'mistakes' that you would only be able to see my going though the 
movies a few frames at a time. Some of them are so tiny you wonder how they 
matter. There's a difference between glaring error that disrupts movie 
continuity, and things like matching dirt smudges at the beginning and the 
end of a movie (that one was in the LotR list!)

Charlene





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive