The good, the bad and the just plain ugly CoS

Andrea kattrap_meow at yahoo.com
Sat Nov 16 07:58:18 UTC 2002


spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
spoiler space
HUGE SPOILERS CONTAINED BELOW!!

So this is going to be disjoined, but so was the movie. On with MNSHO:

Bad screen play, horrible director. If it wasn't for having such a huge fan base already and having such magnificent actors and actresses in it, this movie would flop- as in 1/2 a star flop. 
IT'S NOT WORTH STAYING THROUGH THE CREDITS FOR THE EXTRA!! 
Wait for the DVD so you can fast forward.

-General comments:
< Percy's prefect badge=RED, Tom's prefect badge=GREEN (can only tell in the chamber (flashback is Black and White)
< Lucius's cane: Wonderful!! Snake head on the end with green eyes, but wait! The cane is a sheath for his wand! Beautiful!!
<Ron wearing his red sweater from PS/SS at Diagon Alley

Scene problems:
-In Snape's office: The lighting and filters on the camera were different when close-up with Snape vs. any other shot. EDITING!!!
Snape stalking Harry and Ron around the table was beautiful!

-Womping willow: well done with special effects, but shouldn't it have looked like a willow tree not a tall living stump with boxing gloves on?

-Myrtle flooding the bathroom: ALL the sinks were turned on.

-"study session" scene WITH GINNY THERE is followed by Harry finding Justin. How is our little Ginny supposed to be behind all of this?

-Hagrid coming into D'dore's office: *holding a dead chicken*

-2nd Quidditch match: Hufflepuff is on the pitch? I would think someone (probably McGonagall since she arrived from that direction) would have called them down. 

-Chamber: Can this basilisk not smell? I clearly see nostrils. For a snake it looks a lot like a dinosaur, with all those teeth...

-After chamber in Dumbledore's office: Talking about Harry being in the wrong house: D'dore states that Harry has qualities which *Voldemort* himself looks for. Shouldn't that be *Slytherin? *
Lucius talking: AHHHH! The nasty *wooo look at my eyes* lighting. Horrible!
(well done acting, BAD lighting)

-AK: I'm not going to say that he was or was not saying it, as we have not heard the correct pronunciation for it. Snape's Expelliarmus was pronounced as two words...

Acting:
-Ginny's acting: Ug. they would have been better off finding someone who can ACT and change their hair color (if indeed that is her natural color).
-Lucius, Lockhart and Snape: wonderfully acted. 
-Ron: well, they didn't give him a lot of room here, so no comment.
-Harry: better than PS/SS, some parts done perfectly
-Hermione: Mudblood bit in Hagrid's hut: is she going for an Oscar? <Cue loud music> <Stand up, walk away from group, turn, look all misty-eyed><speak lines>. BLECH!

I think that was a whole dollar worth of two cents, and it took me a while to try and spell everything correctly and type all this, so I hope no one has beat me to the important points of my rant.
:)
Andrea/Kattrap






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive