[HPFGU-Movie] Saw it for the second time...

Richasi richasi at azlance.com
Wed Nov 20 22:46:20 UTC 2002


> S
> P
> O
> I
> L
> E
> R
> S

Wanda Said:

> it really slows down the end of the movie, and it doesn't fit with 
> what's just come before.  Why on earth didn't they just film the 
> pyjama party that was in the book, and have Hagrid come charging in 
> to be mobbed by his friends? There was no need for all that 
> formality at the end.

In many ways I don't mind the Hagrid scene, but I would have
liked to have seen them just end it with the big hug. Dumbledore
could have started making his end of term announcements and then
Hermione could have entered the great hall with all the others 
who had been petrified, and then focused on the big hug to end the
movie.

Not too out of character at least, considering everyone was against
Harry in the books and only warmed up to him after Hermione was
petrified. So the ending I just spelled out there would have been
appropriate (at least more so than having this awkward clapping at
Hagrid).

Though, I guess he could be more loved than we know. Especially by
the Gryffindors for sure, but we never really know how well Hagrid
is liked from the Ravenclaws or Hufflepuffs...

Richasi







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive