[HPFGU-Movie] Re: dvd deleted scenes

[Taryn Kimel]

Chthonia:
1) Draco reacted as if he *hated* Lucius - also OOC, IMHO.  That 
level of discord between the two would surely presage some major 
teenage rebellion on Draco's part later on, and there's been no sign 
of that so far.

Me:
I'll disagree with that. It came across to me much more as if Draco just sort've shrunk down and felt rebuked and intimidated, but I didn't see /hatred/.

Chtonia:
4) Were they really implying that Borgin saw the diary? OK, that 
might have made things clearer for viewers who hadn't seen the books, 
but I can't believe Lucius would have been that stupid.

Me:
I've been wondering what it is that Borgin comments on... I can't be thinking why they would stick lines like that in if it wasn't about the diary, but I couldn't possibly imagine Lucius being so stupid. And then certain other questions would pop up--how did Borgin recognize the diary for something other than a normal diary? Did he see the back and, thus, the "Tom Marvolo Riddle" inscription? So how did /he/ know Voldemort's real identity?

Chtonia:
5) And were they also implying that Draco saw Harry?!  At least that 
explains the ridiculous way that Harry got caught by the Hand in the 
final cut, but surely Draco would have said something to his father?  
Or at least questioned Harry about it?

Me:
I did actually have a first initial instinct that Draco had seen Harry, but he didn't look nearly shocked enough. I'm convinced he was just looking with interest at the items in the store. Draco would've been /way/ more shocked to find Harry down in Knockturn Alley.

--Taryn

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]