Stupid question about Sirius Black

[Amy Z]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, rvotaw at i... wrote:
> I have an incredibly stupid question, so stupid that I wouldn't 
post it on the 
> main list.  In fact, it does relate to filming, so it sort of 
belongs here 
> anyway.  In PoA, when was Sirius seen in a crystal ball?  I've had 
a horrible 
> mental block and don't remember whether it happened in the book or 
not.

Hm.  Well, whether *Sirius* was seen in the crystal ball is a matter 
of interpretation.  Trelawney said she saw the *Grim.*  Maybe she 
did, maybe she didn't; maybe what she saw was a big black dog, not 
the Grim.  No one saw a man resembling Sirius.

HTH,
Amy