A wacky theory about Trelawny's part

[daluben4]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Beth in Sacramento" 
<Tasukibeth1 at c...> wrote:
...
> Which leads me to this unlikely and farfetched theory:
> On Mugglenet.com, I noticed that in the cast list for the third 
> movie, an actress named Sally Mortemore seems to be billed as 
playing 
> Madam Pince (the librarian). This struck me as noticeably odd, 
> because I have read PoA twice, and I don't remember any instances 
> where Madam Pince did or said anything even remotely important or 
> memorable enough to make it into a movie. The actress has appeared 

Assuming the Madam Pince part is very small, as in the books, perhaps 
Mortemore could play both Pince & Trelawney.  Even without book 5, it 
doesn't seem likely that Kloves would have left Trelawney out of the 
screenplay because there is a strong hint in PoA, via Dumbledore, 
that her first prophecy (the one in OoTP) is going to be important 
later on.  Also, I would think that completely deleting a recurring 
character like Trelawney is the kind of thing Kloves would have asked 
JKR about first.