Still bugging me about CoS....

[shannon.koch at pharma.novartis.com]

I have to agree that there are certain scenes in the film that I would have
loved to see and others that were changed and I did not like, but that is
the problem with reading the novels before seeing it and the time limits, I
guess.  I had actually seen the first movie before reading the books and
liked it so much I decided to give the books a whirl (Of course now I am
addicted) and I have to admit, I was so disappointed with scenes I thought
should have been in the movie that weren't.

I know PoA is going to be the same way because they made it into only one
film and even stretching it to 3 hours, there is no way to get everything
into it that the fans truly want to see.  I just hope for GoF and OoP they
break the movies into 2 parts, filming them into a 5-6 hour movie and
releasing like the Matrix so we can get a true feel for what the books are.
There is no way either of these books can be condensed into 2-3 hours and
give a true interpretation of the writing.



Shannon