Movie Hints
Diana
dianasdolls at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 2 02:40:03 UTC 2003
Andrea wrote:
> Since CoS has been on HBO a billion times this month, I've been
> watching it a lot more than I normally would and have noticed a
few
> things.
Diana (me) writes:
Me too! LOL If the movie comes on when I've just got the TV on for
background noise, I turn it to CoS.
Andrea again:
> First, during the dueling club scene when Snape goes to get rid of
> the snake, he says something that I can't remember and
> then "Evanesca." Now, I don't remember ever hearing
the "Evanesco"
> command before OoP; however, this clearly is the same type of
> command. My guess is that JK shared this incantation with Chris
> Columbus during the making of CoS.
>
> This leads me to my second observation, and question. While from
GoF
> on, we are aware of "Stupify" and "Impedimenta", I do not recall
the
> incantation Harry uses to get rid of the spiders in the CoS movie.
> Riddle is heard using it during the "50 years ago" scene when he
> catches Hagrid, and Harry then uses it when he and Ron are in the
> hollow with Aragog and his extended family - more specifically, he
> uses it when Ron is being attacked by the spider once they get
back into the car. Now, the exact incantation is escaping me right
now, but I know that it did not ring any bells with me as far as the
spell being in any of the books.
> Do you think that this incantation will end up in either books 6
or 7, just like the "Evanesca" showed up as "Evanesco" in OoP?
Diana (me) writes:
I believe the spell is "arronia exemay" or "arronia exebay". I'm
sure the spelling is incorrect as I'm just spelling it according to
how it sounds like it's spelled. The spell Snape uses for the snake
in the dueling scene is "e perra evanesca", again I'm guessing on
the spelling.
Harry using the spell in Aragog's den strikes me as a way the
filmmaker tried to give an example of how good (really good) Harry
does under pressure. After all, Harry successfully uses an unknown
spell he only heard ONCE within the memory inside Riddle's diary -
and quite a bit later than when he first heard it as well. In the
book, Harry does not try any spells against the spiders, but in the
movie, he repeats the spell performed by Riddle in the memory he
witnessed. The exact spell Riddle performed in the memory is not
given in the book, though he did perform a spell to open Aragog's
box. So, either JKR gave the filmmakers a latin-words spell they
could use in the movie, or the filmmakers just added it on their
own. If she did give them the words to use, then I think your idea
that this spell could appear in future books is a good one.
Diana L.
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive