CoS deleted scenes

Nia <penumbra10@yahoo.com> penumbra10 at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 16 16:16:36 UTC 2003


 "Richelle Votaw" wrote:
> Mugglenet has a list of deleted scenes that will be on the CoS 
DVD, confirmed by the BBFC, with running time down to the hundreth 
of a second.  <snip>:
> 
> 00:03:11:16 | 2 - LUCIUS LIQUIDATES --Gotta be in Borgin's, right?
> 00:00:22:19 | 3 - HARASSED HARRY --Something else in Knockturn 
Alley maybe?  
> 00:00:27:17 | 4 - JOYRIDE --Flying car, I assume
> 00:00:28:02 | 5 - QUICKSPELL --Filch's office?
> 00:00:24:10 | 6 - SHUTTERBUG --Something with Colin, I assume
> 00:01:15:05 | 7 - POP QUIZ --Lockhart's quiz on himself
> 00:00:18:19 | 8 - QUIDDITCH --obvious, must be that bit with Harry 
flying through a crowd of students
> 00:00:19:16 | 9 - DUEL --something in the dueling club, one would 
assume
> 00:00:48:22 | 10 - HARRY PONDERS --err, okay
> 00:01:04:13 | 11 - HARRY EAVESDROPS --library?
> 00:00:52:06 | 12 - IS THAT A ROOSTER IN YOUR HAND? --Hagrid in the 
hall
> 00:01:15:01 | 13 - IDENTITY CRISIS --Harry?
> 00:00:29:09 | 14 - POLLY JUICE --what did they cut out?
> 00:00:18:20 | 15 - DOUBLE TROUBLE --err?
> 00:01:44:20 | 16 - RIDDLE ME THIS --extension of talk with Riddle?
> 00:00:18:24 | 17 - RUDE AWAKENING --who?
> 00:00:17:10 | 18 - GOING UNDERCOVER --huh?
> 00:00:39:13 | 19 - WHEN GOOD CARS GO BAD--Flying car again (post 
Whomping Willow?) 

Me:
I have two questions:
  
1. As these scenes are just a few seconds each, what, can anyone 
imagine, was the reasoning behind not adding say, the Lockhart test 
scene or Hagrid rooster scene or any of the other scenes that would 
have helped develop the story a bit better?  I realize that time was 
a primary factor, but most of these are so incredibly short, and not 
all of them need have been used, only those that helped the 
exposition of the story.  (One of my big problems with CoS was the 
way the scenes were tacked onto each other with nearly no 
transistion or explaination between--just off we go, then, to the 
next and the next and the next.)  

2.  Forgive me if this question has already been asked but, are 
these scenes to be integrated into the film, as deleted scenes were 
in LOTR (and worked so very well,) or are we going to have to view 
them as a string of unrelated bits independent of the main film? 
Does anyone know?
--Nia 





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive