Lupin Cast?

[crookshanks731@sbcglobal.net <crookshanks731@sbcglobal.net>]

Ok I get your point...lol  
I didn't mean they should be attractive for romatinc roles..I have 
never thought this..I knowHP isnt about romance..however just by the 
description in the books I get the picture of a rather attractive 
man...does this make me a bad person???

LOL

And as for Lupin...I guess Thewlis will do..lol I will admit to never 
have seen him in a movie so I might be surprised with him..

Amanda
AccioPotter--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Emily F" 
<potterfan23 at h...> wrote:
> acciopotter wrote:
> >I agree with not being thrilled about the choice for Lupin...And I 
am
> >not happy at all with the rumors about Gary Oldman playing 
Sirius...I
> >wihs someone could tell me what in the world the casting directors
> >were thinking when they let him in on it.
> 
> I'll tell you what they were thinking.  They watched several actors 
actually 
> take on these roles, and Thewlis and Oldman played their respective 
parts 
> the best.  What else matters?
> 
> Someone else brought up the subject of the two men as romantic 
leads (this 
> is a general comment, I'm not suggesting that this is what 
acciopotter was 
> thinking).  This is one of my HP pet peeves, so I feel the need to 
chime in. 
>   That idea seems to be unfortunately prevalent in fandom.  Since 
when are 
> they romantic leads?  What evidence do we have that either will 
be "hooked 
> up" with another character by the end of the series?  None 
whatsoever.  
> Rowling has said that Sirius is meant to be "dead sexy" (I'll get 
to that in 
> a moment), but there's no mention that Rowling even intended for 
Remus to be 
> attractive.  Down, girls.  Thewlis will do a great job.  He already 
put on 
> an excellent performance for the casting directors.
> 
> As for this Sirius being dead sexy thing...  Who's definition 
of "dead 
> sexy"?  That's right: Joanne Rowling's.  Not yours, not mine.  Do I 
think 
> Gary Oldman is attractive?  Yes, if you look at normal photos of 
him.  (It 
> seems that any role he in which he is cast is made to look as 
unattractive 
> as humanly/inhumanly possible.)  Does Rowling?  Maybe, but no one 
seems to 
> care about her opinion.  Do I think men on motorcycles are sexy?  
No, yuck.  
> I guess I disagree with her.  :-)  I'm not sure if I'm making my 
point or 
> not, so let me try again.  Rowling said that Sirius was dead sexy.  
Fans say 
> that the most attractive actor (in each person's opinion!) must be 
cast.  
> Who ought to be "right" in this case?
> 
> Emily, who thinks Gary Oldman is an outstanding actor, and looks 
forward to 
> meeting godfather!Gary.  ;-)
> 
> _________________________________________________________________
> STOP MORE SPAM with the new MSN 8 and get 2 months FREE*  
> http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail