Snape in the Shack (was Prisoner's hopes and dreams)

[stray_bludger <vampirealchemist@hotmail.com>]

Besides making us Snapefans happy, Snape's presence in the Shack 
could give the filmmakers an opportunity to show how much Snape hated 
the Marauders, especially James, which was omitted at PS. This could 
make his reasons for loathing Harry clearer than what the movie has 
already portrayed. And also, Snape has to give Fudge his account of 
the events in the Shack, leading to the "capture" of Sirius Black and 
showing how Harry's version of what happened is less believable, 
which is what urged Harry and Hermione to go back in time to fix 
things in the first place.

--Dianne
who has been lurking here for a long, long time

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, Meliss9900 at a... wrote:
> I do think that Snape being at the Sheirking Shack is important if 
for no 
> reason other to show the mutual hatred he and Sirius have for one 
another.  
> The Dementors being at the Quidditch game is less crucial because 
their 
> effect on Harry is demonstrated during the train ride.  No one else 
has a 
> reaction that drastic. A quick explaination from Dumbledore as to 
the 
> possible causes (ie he has a more horrible things happen in his 
past than his 
> classmates ect) and we can move on to his learning the Patronus.
> 
> JMO
> Melissa
> 
> 
>  
> 
> 
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]