[HPFGU-Movie] Re: COS Puppet Theatre and some Behind-the-Scenes COS pics

Melissa McCarthy risako at nexusanime.com
Sun Jan 5 23:18:18 UTC 2003


> Since this is the movie list, though, let me make this post fully on
> topic by asking a question - those of you who came to the HP series and
> the fandom through the books - do you consider the films to be
> canonical, and if so, why?

I consider the films to be their own canon and the books to be a completely
separate canon.  I'm not overly fond of the alternate-universes theory, but
in this case, it's the only way I can enjoy both without having my head
explode trying to reconcile the two.  This also eliminates the "gosh, I
would never have cast that actor for that character" difficulty, because in
a way it's not the same character at all.  I don't have any logical
explanation for this theory; basically I choose to believe it because it
makes me happy ^^

Melissa







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive