Has you image of the characters changed?

Scott <insanus_scottus@yahoo.co.uk> insanus_scottus at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Jan 25 04:34:59 UTC 2003


I think this is a really interesting question that...erm...well I 
*hate* to say that I think of the movie characters now, because that 
makes my imagination sound a bit uhhh nonexistent, and that simply 
isn't true. (not that I'm trying to offend anyone by that remark, 
but you know what I mean...right?) The truth is I think it's a 
mixture of the two.

However more than picturing Dan et al. when I read I *hear* them. 
There are definitely some lines that come out in Dan's voice in my 
head. Is that weird? 

Assuming clever list format:

Characters that have in some way fused with my imagination
--Dan Radcliffe as Harry
--Emma Watson as Hermione
--Robbie Coltrane as Hagrid
--Maggie Smith as Professor McGonagall
--Sean Biggerstaff as Oliver Wood
--John Hurt as Ollivander
--Alan Rickman as Snape (sometimes. I'm beginning to warm to that 
odd cadence in voice- something that in the past really grated on my 
nerves.)
--David Bradley as Argus Filch
--Christian Coulson as Tom Riddle

Hmmm...
--Jason Issacs...I can't decide
--Rupert Grint...???

Characters that...well...not so much.
--Richard Harris as Dumbledore
--The Phelps twins as Gred and Forge
--Dobby
--Tom Felton as Draco Malfoy
--whatever it was as Firenze

That's really the only one's I can think of at the moment...well 
think of with the aid of imdb.com that is...

speaking of which did anyone ever decide if that Knockturn Alley 
witch *was* Jo? I'mSure it's been mentioned, but imdb lists her for 
the part.

Seriously though for the most part the characters do fit in some 
form or fashion. I also, after watching SS, went back and read CoS 
*trying* to picture the characters and...it didn't really fit. Now I 
find that they slip in unwarranted. (because they fit so well and 
not because I am being lax.)

Speaking of which..more than characters I think that the movies have 
changed my sense of the settings...I *love* the Gryffindor Common 
room (I want to live there), and for some reason I always though the 
Dursley's house was detached or semi-detached, never in a row, but 
now I see it a bit differently.

I didn't picture the King's Cross barrier quite like that, but then 
thats always been a problem as there isn't a barrier b/w 9and10 at 
all.

The Castle, well...I love the great hall it's just how I imagined 
it, but there doesn't seem to be an entrance hall...hmmm.

I'd be interested to know what you guys thought of the sets in 
addition to characters.

Scott





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive