[HPFGU-Movie] Re: My Thoughts on the Deleted CoS Scenes

[Lea]

Tom Wall <thomasmwall at yahoo.com> wrote:
Phyllis wrote:

I think it's a fairly major 
omission in the movie that they 
don't mention Filch's squib-ness, 
but this scene wouldn't have 
accomplished this - Harry didn't 
even open the envelope, and 
there's no mention of Filch 
being a squib. 

Tom writes:
Sorry to have completely missed the ball on this thread, but I just 
have to add that I'm tremendously disappointed that this wasn't in 
the film.

Mostly, I'm disappointed because I'd like to believe that none of 
these bits of information are meant for the GARBAGESCOW - and I was 
sure that Filch's lack of magic would be somehow pivotal in a later 
novel. And since, JKR is in touch with Steve Kloves, and warns him 
that certain things must remain, I must confess that the lack of 
Filch's Squib situation is a let-down.

So much for Filch-the-ultimate-possible-traitor theory. Oh well. ;-)

-Tom


Lea:

don't give up hope on that thought..   they obviously have the footage and can always use it in a flashback.  especially since the movie had the boys directly into Snape's office from the top of the stairs.  since Filch is the only squib (that we know of) - there has to be some importance to him working at Hogwart's.




---------------------------------
Post your free ad now! Yahoo! Canada Personals


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]