[HPFGU-Movie] Re: new uniforms? & new Dumbledore

[LeeMunLim03 at aol.com]

I dont know if your being sarcastic but its funny!!  No it won't be subtile 
for me.  I understand Dumbledore but I dont know about the rest.

Kyle 


In a message dated 5/26/03 1:21:06 PM Eastern Daylight Time, 
irene_mikhlin at yahoo.com writes:

> --- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, LeeMunLim03 at a... wrote:
> >True schools do change and all but I am just worried Alfonso will
> put too 
> >much of his mark on the Prisoner of Azkaban!  I like Sophia don't
> want change but 
> >on the other hand its okay if it changes in a subtile way like for
> instance 
> >Ron, Harry or Hermione say what happened with the common room or
> something like 
> >that.
> 
> Excuse me while I'm having hysterical laugh here. I just can see it:
> Ron: "Blimey, Harry, what happened to Dumbledore? He looks completely
> different."
> Hermione: "Oh, will you ever read "Hogwarts, the history"? Honestly,
> it says clearly on page 536 that all Hogwarts headmasters
> traditionally go through plastic surgery when they reach 150". Or when
> our soap opera reaches 150 episodes, whichever comes the first.
> 
> Will that be subtle enough for you, Kyle?
> 
> Irene
> 
> 
> >
> >Kyle Longbottom 
> >
> >
> >
> >In a message dated 5/26/03 11:52:25 AM Eastern Daylight Time, 
> >sophiamcl at h... writes:
> >
> >>
> >>>Kriselda wrote:
> >>><<<Oh, one thought I had about the new uniforms - it's
> >>>not unheard of for a school to redesign their uniforms
> >>
> >>>And now me (Odile):
> >>Tom Riddle and Moaning Myrtle had
> >>>different style robes from the contemporary (and
> >>>living) students.  ^_^
> >
> >>
> >>Excellent points! Even so, I don't have a problem personally with
> continuity 
> >>
> >>glitches--and I don't think there should necessarily have to be a
> "logical" 
> >>explanation for them. (I am talking about the visual aspect of the
> movies 
> >>now, not the scripts, which is a different story entirely). I am
> sure there 
> >>will 
> >>be some visual continuity-glitches, simply due to the new
> director. (For 
> >>instance, the back-drop to Hagrid's cabin ought to look quite
> different 
> >>now)I 
> >>rather think it would speak against Cuaron if there weren't. I
> don't want 
> >>him 
> >>to plod on in Columbus's footsteps. 
> >>I figure there will be plenty of things to recognize and feel at
> home with 
> >>as it 
> >>is. Many of the sets will be the same, won't they? We probably
> won't see a 
> >>new Gryffindor common room or Great Hall--so bring on the new
> uniforms, 
> >>Harry's new and improve hair-style, and, under the circumstances,
> the new 
> >>Dumbledore!
> >>
> >>Columbus did a fantastic job of bringing Hogwarts to life on the
> screen and 
> >>make it seem real, but I'm ready for Cuaron. I WANT to see a new
> take on 
> >>Harry and his world.  Now that Columbus has broken ground, I would
> find it 
> >>enriching to see the touch of a different mind on the script, a
> different 
> >>vision. 
> >>Columbus's view, entchanting as it was, is only one of many exciting 
> >>possibilities. Cuaron's vision ought to include differences in the
> whole as 
> >>well 
> >>as the detail.  It'll be like comparing to artists takes on the same 
> >>subject. One 
> >>doesn't detract from the other, and there is no absolute truth in
> what 
> >>Harry's 
> >>world looks like. It belongs to anyone who can fashion images in
> her head, 
> >>and we're about to meet a new mind on screen. (Well, a
> conglomerate of 
> >>minds would be  more accurate) I look forward to it!!!
> >>
> >>(Having said that, I admit, I'd have a big problem with changing the 
> >>trio...But 
> >>that's not to worry about yet, so I can afford to extol the
> virtues of 
> >>CHANGE!)
> >>
> >>Sophia



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]